Astyages: the king behind the villain

‘The Defeat of Astyages’, a tapestry designed by Maximilien de Haese and woven by Jacques van der Borght (1771-1775).
Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

According to the Greek historian Herodotus (Histories 1.107–130), Astyages, king of the Medes, was haunted by a unsettling prophecy. He had dreamed that his daughter Mandane would give birth to a child who would overthrow him and take his throne. Determined to prevent this, he ordered his trusted servant Harpagus to kill the baby, named Cyrus. Harpagus, however, could not bring himself to kill the child and instead handed him over to a shepherd, who raised him as his own son.

Years later, Astyages discovered that Cyrus was still alive. Furious that Harpagus had disobeyed him, he came up with a terrible punishment. He invited Harpagus to a feast, secretly served him the flesh of his own son, and revealed the awful truth only after the meal. Harpagus hid his anger but never forgot what Astyages had done. When Cyrus eventually rebelled against his grandfather, Astyages put Harpagus in command of the Median army. Harpagus took the opportunity to get his revenge, turning against his former master and helping Cyrus win the war. In the end, the very prophecy that Astyages had tried so hard to prevent came true, largely because of his own actions.

Herodotus presents Astyages as a cruel and paranoid ruler who brought about his own downfall. Yet this well-known story tells us surprisingly little about the historical Astyages. Herodotus also tells us that Astyages succeeded his father Cyaxares, ruled for 35 years, and was connected to the Lydian royal family through marriage. But apart from these details, almost everything he tells us about Astyages concerns how he lost his throne.

Continue reading “Astyages: the king behind the villain”

The Scythian Empire and the limits of speculation

A speculative reconstruction of the supposed ‘Scythian Empire’. There is no contemporary evidence for such an empire or its territorial extent.
Antiquistik, CC BY-SA 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Those familiar with the history of the ancient Near East will have heard of the Assyrian, Babylonian, and Persian Empires. They may also have encountered the debate over the existence of a Median Empire. But was there ever a Scythian Empire? According to the Greek historian Herodotus, there was. In Histories 1.103–106, he describes a Scythian king named Madyes, son of Protothyes, who allegedly ruled over ‘Asia’ for 28 years and led his warriors as far south as Palestine, where the Egyptian pharaoh Psamtik I persuaded him to turn back.

Madyes is also said to have driven back the Median king Cyaxares during his first attempt to besiege Nineveh, the Assyrian capital. The Scythians subsequently subjugated the Medes, imposing tribute while at the same time plundering their territories. After having suffered 28 years of humiliations, Cyaxares invited the Scythian leaders to a banquet, got them drunk, and murdered them, thereby restoring Median supremacy, before fulfilling his original ambition of taking Nineveh.

It is a compelling story, but one that is difficult to reconcile with what we know about this period. Neither Assyrian royal inscriptions and correspondence, Babylonian chronicles, nor the Old Testament mention a Scythian Interregnum, or even widespread Scythian raids across the region, during the latter half of the seventh century BCE.

Continue reading “The Scythian Empire and the limits of speculation”

Was Ahaz of Judah bandwagoning or balancing?

Two blocs in the Syro-Ephraimite War (734-732 BCE): Assyria and its vassals in red, the anti-Assyrian coalition in blue.
By Daan Nijssen (CC BY 3.0)

In 734 BCE, King Ahaz of Judah faced an immediate crisis. King Rezin of Damascus and King Pekah of Israel had joined forces and invaded his kingdom. According to Isaiah 7, they even intended to depose him and replace him with another ruler. Ahaz responded by appealing to King Tiglath-pileser III of Assyria, saying: “I am your servant and vassal. Come up and save me from the kings of Damascus and Israel.” He sent silver and gold from the temple and palace, and Assyria intervened.

From the perspective of international-relations theory, Ahaz’s decision raises a deceptively simple question: was he “bandwagoning” or “balancing”? In traditional balance-of-power theory, balancing means opposing a stronger power, either by strengthening oneself or by joining forces with others, whereas bandwagoning means aligning with the stronger side rather than resisting it. The distinction seems straightforward: weaker states can either combine against power or accommodate it.

At first sight, Ahaz appears to have bandwagoned. Assyria was by far the strongest power in the Near East. Damascus, Israel and Judah were comparatively small kingdoms operating under the shadow of a rapidly expanding empire. Rather than joining Rezin and Pekah in resisting Tiglath-pileser, Ahaz aligned himself with the strongest actor in the system. In the most straightforward sense, he chose the stronger side. But this interpretation depends on what exactly states are supposed to balance against.

Continue reading “Was Ahaz of Judah bandwagoning or balancing?”

How Israel navigated Assyrian power

The kingdoms of the southern Levant in 738 BCE. Gilead, Galilee and Dor may have formed a breakaway kingdom under Pekah, while Menahem ruled over Samaria. The supposed “breakaway regions” were annexed by Tiglath-pileser III after he had defeated Pekah.
By Daan Nijssen (CC BY 3.0)

When studying Assyrian imperialism, one encounters a striking paradox: the phenomenon is unusually well documented, yet unusually difficult to view from any other perspective than an Assyrian one. Royal inscriptions describe military campaigns and diplomatic exchanges in considerable detail, but they do so through the highly ideological voice of the Assyrian king. Sources produced by the kingdoms confronted with Assyrian imperial ambitions, by contrast, are far scarcer. This makes the biblical book of 2 Kings exceptionally valuable: it preserves something we rarely possess for the Neo-Assyrian period: a sustained account of how smaller states actually dealt with Assyrian power.

Its value lies especially in the practical details. The text shows rulers paying tribute, building alliances, invoking external support, and choosing between resistance or accommodation, as well as the domestic political struggles that could shape those decisions. These are precisely the kinds of processes that Assyrian royal inscriptions tend to reduce to formulaic categories such as loyalty, submission and rebellion.

Read alongside the Assyrian evidence and through an international-relations lens, 2 Kings therefore offers a rare opportunity to examine imperialism as an interactive political process: not simply as the advance of an overwhelmingly powerful empire imposing its will, but as the product of repeated encounters between Assyria and local actors pursuing their own strategies of survival and autonomy.

Continue reading “How Israel navigated Assyrian power”